Starting pitching upgrades will surely be one of the forefront focuses of the Baltimore Orioles before the 2027 season gets underway...especially with the free agent future of Trevor Rogers uncertain. As a team that's shied away from bigger free agent starters in recent seasons, the Orioles have been linked to plenty of mid-range names. One of those arms that insiders have linked to them was 2026 World Series champion Dustin May.
However, while May might've once been a target, that thought quickly came and went after May reportedly landed with the Chicago White Sox on Tuesday. According to FanSided MLB insider Robert Murray, the 29-year-old right-hander will head to the Southside on a 3-year, $52.5 million contract -- or in other terms, he'll be making $17.5 million per season.
BREAKING: Free-agent pitcher Dustin May and the Chicago White Sox are in agreement on a three-year contract worth just north of $50 million, according to sources familiar with the deal.
— Robert Murray (@ByRobertMurray) November 17, 2026
If that AAV sounds high, it's probably because it is. May isn't devoid of talent by any means, but he's a mid-range starter at best after a second-straight season with a mid-to-high-4.00s ERA split between four different teams. In fact, in 2026, between the St. Louis Cardinals and Milwaukee Brewers, May followed up his near-5.00 ERA mark in 2025 with a 4.70 ERA and 1.32 WHIP across 31 starts.
His numbers aren't undesirable by any means, and with underlying metrics such as an 85th percentile fastball velocity, perhaps in theory May could've work in the bottom end of this rotation behind names like Kyle Bradish and Shane Baz. However, a $17.5 million price tag seems outrageous for someone as comparatively mediocre as May.
If this is the price for lower-end impact free agent starters, perhaps the Orioles will have to shift their focus elsewhere. And maybe that doesn't mean settling for overpaying a similar arm to May, but perhaps going in the complete opposite direction and finally throwing caution to the wind and making that long-awaited big free-agent swing for their rotation.
Dustin May signing with White Sox could open up new offseason strategy for Orioles
If May is worth $17.5 million a season in this free-agent market, then how will the rest of the market fall into place? Is that now the going rate for a fourth or fifth starter?
Overpaying for an arm like that seems like a poor business decision for a team that's looking to get over the hump and make it back to the postseason. So if it's going to take overpaying to bring in starting pitching upgrades, why not go all-out for top-end names?
While someone like Tarik Skubal might be a nice dream, with so many top contenders eagerly seeking his signature and the fact he's in a tier of his own amongst starting pitching free agents. However, Skubal isn't the only impactful front-end starter on the open market. Names like Rogers, as well as Michael King or veteran stars like Kevin Gausman and Sonny Gray, are available and could give them the top-end impact they desperately need and are worth more of an overpay than middling names like May.
With the lockout all but inevitable for Dec. 2, the Orioles will have plenty of work to do over the next few weeks if they don't want to postpone their upgrades to an unknown date under an unknown new CBA. And now that first notable pitching domino is off the board with May, Mike Elias and Jared Banner may need to accelerate their plans that much quicker if they want to get their offseason moving before the uncertainty of a work stoppage comes into play.
