We’ve now passed the qualifying offer decision deadline and the Rule 5 protection deadline, which led to a fair amount of activity for the Baltimore Orioles. It’s now time to turn our attention to Friday’s non-tender deadline. Teams have already made some decisions by releasing or trading players they were likely to non-tender, but Friday’s deadline is sure to bring another wave of surprises, trades, and roster movement.
The Orioles' list of arbitration-eligible players going into the offseason didn’t feature many tough decisions. Outfielder Leody Taveras was projected to make $3.7 million next year, but after hitting .219 this past season and showing declining defense, Baltimore quickly elected to outright Taveras at the start of the offseason. He declined an assignment to Triple-A and elected free agency.
RHP Codi Heuer and RHP Albert Suarez, both estimated at a salary of $1.1 million next season, have also moved on and are now free agents.
That leaves RHP Felix Bautista ($2.4 million), OF Colton Cowser ($2.2 million), SS Gunnar Henderson ($14.1 million), and 3B Jordan Westburg ($1.5 million) left for the Orioles to make decisions on. All are expected to be tendered contracts.
That doesn’t mean the Orioles won’t be active on Friday. They were already reportedly in discussions with Tampa Bay about a trade for catcher Nick Fortes, a non-tender candidate who was ultimately shipped to Boston. Looking at the rest of the non-tender candidates around the league, there are a few other names who may be of interest to Baltimore.
The Orioles don't need to find starters or impact players on the non-tender market. They need affordable roster pieces who can address specific weaknesses, and there are a few players who fit that description.
Four non-tender cadidates who the Baltimore Orioles may target
Jo Adell
Tyler O’Neill was signed by the Orioles before the 2025 season to do one thing: mash lefties. Unfortunately, injuries have unsurprisingly limited him to a combined 139 games over the last two seasons. He was the first free agent to receive a multi-year contract from then Orioles general manager (now President of Baseball Operations) Mike Elias, a three-year, $49.5 million deal with an opt-out after year one. After a down year, O’Neill opted into the final two years of the deal, leaving the Orioles with a high-priced outfielder who provides very little.
If they can find any way to move on from O’Neill, Jo Adell could be an intriguing replacement. Adell wouldn’t provide the defensive improvements the Orioles are in need of, but his premier bat speed and ability to hit lefties well could produce what they had hoped O’Neill would when he was originally signed.
The 27-year-old hit 37 home runs in 2025 with the Angels and 23 last season with the Angels and Guardians while putting together a string of healthy seasons. In 2026, Adell hit .320 with a .971 OPS against left-handed pitching. That will certainly be attractive to the Orioles.
However, money could be an issue here. Adell is projected to make just under $10 million next season, and O’Neill will pull in $16.5 million. If the Orioles decide to eat O’Neill’s contract and release him, that’s a significant amount of money for a platoon outfielder who provides very little defensive value. Maybe the Orioles have sense from their conversations with other organizations that they may be able to move O’Neill and not have to eat the full amount, which would help. The bat makes a ton of sense, but the money may be too much here when you have to factor in O’Neill.
Garrett Cleavinger
Baltimore is in the market for a left-handed reliever, and Garrett Cleavinger may be the best one available among the non-tender candidates. Cleavinger is projected to make $3.7 million next season, and leave it up to the Rays to potentially have a good arm available at the non-tender deadline.
Originally a third-round pick of the Orioles out of Oregon back in 2015, Cleavinger was traded to Philadelphia before reaching the majors in 2017 as part of a package for RHP Jeremy Hellickson, a trade Orioles fans would rather not revisit.
Cleavinger was limited to 41 innings this season and posted a career-worst 4.79 ERA, but he’s still sitting a hair under 97 mph from the left side and struck out 30% of the batters he faced. He’s also not that far removed from his 2025 season of a 2.35 ERA and 0.95 WHIP across 61 innings.
Given how the market for relievers seems to be shaping up this offseason, it wouldn’t be surprising to see the Orioles target Cleavinger as their left-handed reliever addition given their familiarity with him.
Rafael Marchan
The Orioles are also in the market for a third catcher to work with Samuel Basallo and Carlos Narvaez, and while there are a couple of intriguing options available in free agency, Marchán could be a target for the Orioles if their preference is to have the third catcher they bring in be a defensive specialist.
Marchán is projected to make just $1 million in 2027, but the 27-year-old Venezuelan backstop recorded a measly nine hits in 91 at-bats when he was healthy, and Philadelphia will surely be looking to upgrade the backup catcher spot with 36-year-old JT Realmuto returning.
While Marchán provides virtually nothing with the bat, except the ability to limit strikeouts, his defensive metrics on Baseball Savant grade out very well, including a 1.88-second pop time that ranked in the 86th percentile in baseball last season. He’s a great blocker behind the plate as well.
With underrated catching prospect Ethan Anderson quickly approaching the big leagues, it makes no sense for the Orioles to invest heavily in the third catcher they are on the lookout for, making Marchán an interesting potential target. The Orioles don't need their third catcher to be another offensive weapon. They need someone who can handle the position defensively, provide competent depth, and bridge the gap until Anderson is ready. He’s currently playing in Venezuela, where he’s hitting .267 with more walks than strikeouts in 20 games.
Matt Vierling
The Tigers didn’t wait until Friday’s deadline to move on from Matt Vierling, designating him for assignment on Tuesday along with infielders Jace Jung and Trey Sweeney, and pitcher Jake Miller. He was an obvious non-tender candidate with his projected $3.7 million salary for 2027; he could be someone the Orioles target now that he’s available.
The 30-year-old outfielder is coming off back-to-back injury-plagued seasons; however, a number of his underlying metrics, including his bat speed, remain close to where they were when he was healthy two years ago, and he severely underperformed his expected numbers across the board. Early Steamer projections have him bouncing back a bit in 2027, hitting .242 with a wRC+ of 89 after hitting .207 with a 61 wRC+ this season.
The intrigue with Vierling lies in his defense. Capable of playing all three outfield spots, Vierling features above-average sprint speed and recorded 3 Outs Above Average in center field this past season with the Tigers. He also hit .257 against left-handed pitching, another point of intrigue. The Orioles could view him as a potential bounceback candidate who replaces Leody Tavares.
