Skip to main content

Orioles' aggressive Rule 5 strategy may hint at their view of the upcoming lockout

The Orioles aren't taking any chances
ByNicholas Stevens
Tampa Bay Rays v. Baltimore Orioles
Tampa Bay Rays v. Baltimore Orioles | Michael Mooney/GettyImages

The Baltimore Orioles were one of the busiest teams in the league on Tuesday as the offseason calendar reached the deadline to protect Rule 5-eligible players. The Orioles cleared multiple 40-man spots early in the afternoon before adding a league-high seven prospects to the roster and trading away another to the Athletics. 

Joining the 40-man roster are OF Enrique Bradfield Jr., IF Aron Estrada, RHP Patrick Reilly, RHP Braxton Bragg, RHP Nestor German, RHP Levi Wells, and RHP Michael Forret. 

Orioles add a highly intriguing group of prospects to the 40-man roster

Bradfield’s bat hasn’t quite lived up to expectations since being selected in the first round of the 2022 MLB Draft out of Vanderbilt, but his plus speed and defense are premium major league tools and could become a much-needed asset to the Orioles’ roster at some point in 2027. Estrada is a bit further away from the big leagues, but the 21-year-old second baseman hit .281 with a career-high 21 doubles and 25 home runs between Double-A and Triple-A last season. 

The switch-hitter has spent the last couple of years adding a significant amount of strength to his 5-foot-11 frame, resulting in impressive home run numbers and a 112.3 mph max exit velocity, without sacrificing much of his bat-to-ball skills.

The group of pitchers may be the most fascinating. Patrick Reilly and Braxton Bragg are both coming off strong Arizona Fall League campaigns after missing most of 2025 and 2026 due to Tommy John surgery. Bragg’s first action post-TJ surgery came in the AFL, so he wasn’t yet at full strength in Arizona, but the 26-year-old has shown the ability to flirt with triple digits on the radar gun and attacks hitters with a kitchen-sink approach. 

Reilly sat 95 mph in the AFL with three secondary offerings that produced a whiff rate north of 40%. His control may limit his ceiling as a starter at the next level, but it wouldn’t be surprising to see him working out of the major league bullpen early on in 2027.

Both German and Forret provide the Orioles with quality starting depth. Neither may have an elite offering, but they both bring deep pitch mixes and profile as back-end starters in the big leagues. German may ultimately find himself in a bullpen role with a devastating high-whiff splitter, but he should be one of the first depth options the Orioles turn to next season, along with Trey Gibson. 

Lastly, Levi Wells made just eight appearances in 2026 before he was lost for the year due to core muscle surgery, but with a fastball that touches 100 mph, a full array of offerings, and a strong ability to limit walks, Wells provides the Orioles with another potential optionable reliever in 2027. 

The Orioles moved another one of their Rule 5-eligible arms, RHP Yaqui Rivera, to the Athletics for 20-year-old RHP Josiah Romeo. 

Rivera was a dark-horse 40-man add for the Orioles, but clearly the Orioles didn’t see room to add an eighth player and didn’t want to risk losing him for nothing if there is a Rule 5 draft. Instead, they were able to acquire an intriguing young arm in Romeo. 

The Athletics drafted Romeo in the sixth round of the 2024 MLB Draft out of the Canadian high school ranks after a dominant run as an 18-year-old in the MLB Draft League, where he was four years younger than the average hitter. Romeo logged 107 innings between rookie-ball and Single-A with the A’s in 2026, posting a combined 5.05 ERA with 92 strikeouts and 38 walks. He features a three-pitch mix, and while he didn’t exhibit the greatest strikeout and walk rates, he has shown the ability to fill the strike zone at a young age. He should start 2027 in High-A with the Orioles. 

Does the Orioles' Rule 5 strategy hint at a short lockout?

Both Orioles President of Baseball Operations Mike Elias and general manager Jared Banner said at the GM meetings in Las Vegas that the Orioles were going to operate as if the Rule 5 draft were going to happen at some point. Last time there was a lockout, the Rule 5 draft was canceled, but there’s been no confirmation about firm Rule 5 plans this year. 

Perhaps playing it “safe” and protecting seven players is a sign that the Orioles believe we’re looking at a shorter lockout and the eventual rescheduling of the Rule 5 draft. Not every organization appears to be as confident, if that’s the case. Four teams protected no players, five organizations protected just one player, and numerous ranked prospects were left unprotected.

Regardless, the Orioles added seven players who all have a path to contributing in the big leagues next season, or at least providing valuable depth as they continue their development. They also still have two spots on the 40-man roster available. Next step: open up the wallet and fill those spots with some free agents.   

Add us as a preferred source on Google