Skip to main content

Orioles Rumors: Baltimore inquired about Hunter Goodman, but what does that mean for Samuel Basallo

Another catcher logjam?
ByStephen Parello
Sep 26, 2026; Chicago, Illinois, USA;  Colorado Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman (15) points after he hit a three-run home run during the ninth inning against the Chicago White Sox at Rate Field.  Mandatory Credit: Matt Marton-Imagn Images
Sep 26, 2026; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Colorado Rockies catcher Hunter Goodman (15) points after he hit a three-run home run during the ninth inning against the Chicago White Sox at Rate Field. Mandatory Credit: Matt Marton-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

There was little doubt that the Baltimore Orioles were going to look for help behind the plate this offseason. The pivot from Adley Rutschman to Carlos Narvaez at the trade deadline was not a smooth one, with Narvaez hitting just .104/.198/.117 with the Orioles, and .187/.260/.275 overall in 2026. A glove-first catcher is fine, but that kind of offensive performance is just too ghastly to tolerate.

Narvaez still has options and doesn't hit arbitration until next offseason, so he's the perfect third catcher to stash in Norfolk, especially if he can get right in Triple-A and come back as a guy who can land somewhere between his encouraging 2025 season and this year's dumpster fire.

However, Samuel Basallo needs help. A year into his eight-year, $67 million contract, the 22-year-old hit just .222/.291/.406, but did pop 18 homers in just 112 games. The bigger concern was his defensive ability, specifically the nuances of being a catcher at the big league level.

Still, it wasn't expected that Baltimore would go after a real challenger to Basallo. Instead, targets seemed to be at the Carson Kelly level and below. Kelly would work best in a timeshare, but could take over full-time in the event of injury or if Basallo really struggled. Kelly might want a landing spot where he has a clearer path to a starting role, so we thought the Orioles would be looking at Austin Hedges and his ilk.

So, color us surprised when Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic reported that Baltimore has called the Colorado Rockies to check in on All-Star catcher Hunter Goodman. While it seems talks haven't gotten very far, it's worth questioning what this means for Basallo and his future.

The Orioles' interest in Hunter Goodman is not a Samuel Basallo-Adley Rutschman redux

Part of the reason why the Orioles traded Adley Rutschman was their commitment to Basallo. With Rutschman in the fold for most of 2026, the youngster caught just 63 games, spending another 34 at DH and 12 at first base. A big reason for that was the fact that although Rutschman's bat has been up and down in recent years, he's a fantastic defender behind the plate.

Basallo isn't going to improve defensively without reps, so blocking him at catcher doesn't make sense unless you're looking to move him off the position. However, with Pete Alonso at first, there doesn't really seem to be anywhere for him to go.

Still, it would seem weird to give up on him after just one full season in the majors. On top of that, his defensive metrics weren't all that bad this year. Basallo came in as a 73rd-percentile pitch blocker and ranked in the 69th percentile in cutting down would-be basestealers, thanks in part to a 1.92-second pop time.

On the flip side, he was an abysmal pitch framer, ranking in the ninth percentile. He needs to improve at calling games and handling a pitching staff, and that only comes with experience.

Goodman isn't another Rutschman. He's not a great framer, either, coming in as a 40th percentile performer. His blocking ranked in the 29th percentile, and his ability to throw out base runners was good for a 17th percentile mark. In short, Basallo is the better defensive player when it comes to physical abilities, and it's not particularly close.

The appeal of Goodman is not his glove, but his bat. He slashed .245/.310/.529 with 41 taters in 2026. He wasn't just a Coors Field product either, posting an .882 OPS on the road and a .791 OPS in Colorado. Adding another 40-homer bat alongside Pete Alonso would be huge for the Birds' lineup.

Upgrading the offense is a major need, so this is Mike Elias being advantageous and trying to get a cost-controlled slugger who is under team control for three more years, which in turn would allow him to allocate more money to fix the starting rotation. Most have felt that the outfield was the natural place to find a big bat, but Goodman is a stronger power hitter than anything the team can find in free agency.

So, the idea here seems to be putting Goodman at DH the majority of the time, while having the ability to slide him behind the plate if needed. In that way, Basallo isn't negatively impacted at all, and the thump in the lineup is upgraded dramatically. Basically, this would be the opposite of the Adley Rutschman situation.

Whether or not the Orioles are willing to pony up the prospect capital to make this happen is another story. Theoretically, Elias could scrape together enough from the farm system to get the yes from the Rockies, especially because Colorado is chronically in need of talented young pitching. If he wants to part with those assets, that could be a very different story, though.

Add us as a preferred source on Google