Orioles outfielder Colton Cowser robbed of 2024 AL Rookie of the Year award

Colton Cowser narrowly missed out on the 2024 AL Rookie of the Year award

Wild Card Series - Kansas City Royals v Baltimore Orioles - Game 1
Wild Card Series - Kansas City Royals v Baltimore Orioles - Game 1 | Greg Fiume/GettyImages

On Monday night, MLB announced the Rookie of the Year award winners. Many Orioles fans thought outfielder Colton Cowser was a lock to win the AL award, but unfortunately Cowser fell just shy. Yankees' starter Luis Gil was announced the winner by a thin margin. Gil received 15 first place votes, while Cowser received 13. Yankees' catcher Austin Wells finished a distant third.

Cowser's 4.0 fWAR was best among all AL rookies, and third among all rookies behind just the Padres' Jackson Merrill and the Cubs' Shota Imanaga. The Orioles star finished the year with a .242/.321/.447 slash line with 24 homers and 9 steals. Cowser chipped in strong defense in both center field and in left.

Cowser played in 153 games this year, second among all rookies. With the breakout performance, he cemented himself as a vital part of the Orioles' future. Many fans expected to see this type of performance from star prospect Jackson Holliday but with Cowser now firmly in the mix, the O's are in an extremely desirable spot moving forward.

Orioles rookie robbed in AL award race

From an unbiased angle, Gil did have a strong year. He finished with a 15-7 record in 151.2 innings, pitching to a 3.50 ERA along the way. His 171 strikeouts were second among all rookie pitchers, and first among his AL counterparts.

However, Gil's performance was worth just 2.2 fWAR, coming in at 9th among all rookies. He failed to surpass both Cade Smith and Mason Miller, two AL rookie relievers, in total WAR. Gil's 12.1% walk rate was in the bottom 7th percentile league-wide and he posted a discouraging 4.14 FIP.

In total, Gil won by just 5 points. He was listed on just 26 ballots, meaning 4 voters left him off the ballot. Likewise, Cowser earned just 27 votes. Cowser was far and away the best rookie hitter in the American League, so it seems a bit inexplicable that he'd be left off 3 ballots entirely.

Ultimately, it's disappointing that the Orioles had such a strong candidate to win the award but have come up empty. If Cowser had won, it would have been the second straight year that the O's had a Rookie of the Year award winner. Gunnar Henderson took home the award in 2023. Back in 2022, Adley Rutschman finished second. It's nice that the O's have had three straight top-2 finishes but those two narrowly missed victories are unfortunate.

Schedule