Pete Alonso's first season with the Baltimore Orioles culminated in him being named a Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger finalist. It was a magical year for one of the most impactful free-agent signings in franchise history. While Alonso put up a stat line that is well-deserving of taking home the award, he has some steep competition in the form of division rival Willson Contreras of the Boston Red Sox.
Alonso leads Contreras in terms of power, clocking 43 homers to Contreras's 27 and beating him in slugging .522 to .516. Contreras holds the edge in batting average (.275 to .267) and on-base percentage (.386 to .363). One would figure, then, that this would be a tight race. Well, that is unless you're the Red Sox.
Despite having Contreras under contract for 2027, as well as a reasonable $20 million club option for 2028, Boston went out over the weekend and signed first baseman and outfielder Jake Bauers to a four-year $58 million contract.
The Red Sox are famous for their outfield logjam, a problem they have been very sluggish in addressing. With Jarren Duran, Ceddanne Rafaela, Wilyer Abreu, Roman Anthony, and a nominal outfielder in Masataka Yoshida, there's nowhere out on the grass for Bauers to play. We thought Contreras was entrenched at first base, which makes it hard to envision how much run Bauers could receive there. Then there's how all of this overflows into the DH position. It all begs the question: Is Boston gearing up to trade Contreras?
Did the Red Sox's signing of Jake Bauers confirm Orioles star Pete Alonso's Silver Slugger win over Willson Contreras?
Hysterically, Alonso was the Red Sox's top free-agent target last winter before the Orioles wrestled him away. That's what led Boston to trade for Contreras in the first place.
Now, when we're looking at Silver Slugger campaigns, something becomes clear between Alonso and Contreras. Alonso didn't really do anything out of the ordinary, at least given his career context. The former Mets fan favorite put up a 148 wRC+ in 2026. It's a career-best mark, but not by much. This year was the fourth time he managed a 140 wRC+ or better, and his previous career-high was 144 during his 53-homer rookie season. Even in 2025, he managed a .140 wRC+, proving his dominance.
Contreras also had a career year, but this one was relatively far outside of his norms. He posted a 151 wRC+, but had only one season where he had reached 140 previously. His 27 dingers were also a career best.
That isn't to say that Contreras isn't a good hitter because he is, but rather that his 2026 season was more of an outlier, whereas Alonso's year was simply par for the course.
Now, the Red Sox's move for Bauers isn't really an indication of who will take home the Silver Slugger honor tomorrow evening, but it is curious that Boston seems to be pushing a key player out the door. Maybe the Red Sox seem to have something else up their sleeve, but all this maneuvering at first base should serve as a reminder that the Orioles came out ahead last year, and the Red Sox probably wish that they had Alonso right about now.
