The Tyler O'Neill social media discourse has gotten uncomfortable among Orioles fans

The moment that the Baltimore Orioles' starting lineup gets posted, there is a flurry of tweets, posts, comments, and quotes on every platform where Orioles baseball is discussed. In reading through the storm of lineup-related complaints, the consensus is overwhelming: Orioles fans have had enough of Tyler O'Neill.

When it was originally announced that O'Neill was signing with the Orioles, many fans were optimistic about his arrival. At the time, it was the largest contract the Orioles had handed out under Mike Elias, and O'Neill had an impressive track record against left-handed pitching, which was something that the Orioles and their predominately left handed hitting core of players had struggled with over the past couple of years, culminating in the Orioles being utterly dominated by lefty Cole Ragans in the 2024 playoffs.

Signing O'Neill was a mistake, playing him everyday only makes it worse

Unfortunately, over the last two seasons, O'Neill has been dreadful against left-handed pitching and has only added to the Orioles' struggles against southpaws. O'Neill's struggles aren't just limited to when he's facing lefties. Since joining the Orioles out of the 407 players to get at least 200 plate appearances, O'Neill ranks 397th in WAR. He has provided negative value at the plate, in the outfield, and on the bases. That is the total package of bad baseball.

In 2025, O'Neill spent most of the season on the injured list, and as disappointing as that season was for him, at least for the fans, he was mostly out of sight and out of mind. In 2026, O'Neill has been mostly healthy outside of a bout with the flu that resulted in a concussion, and as the team has performed below expectations, O'Neill's consistent presence in the middle of the lineup, especially against left-handed pitching, has begun to draw the ire of the fanbase.

In Monday's game against the Rays, the Orioles did finally move him down in the lineup, but before that, he had been hitting in the five hole behind Pete Alonso in the vast majority of his starts. This set him up for a bunch of first and second inning plate appearances with runners on, of which he capitalized zero times. That is not an exaggeration; this season, O'Neill is batting .000 in the first and second innings. No hits, no RBI, just a 35% K rate.

The reason there is so much anger and frustration directed at O'Neill is because of the way he's being used by the Orioles. If he were in the dog house and was riding the bench, only getting playing time as a pinch hitter, Orioles fans would start to feel bad for him. Slumping sucks, and obviously, O'Neill does not want to be one of the worst players in the league.

However, despite his performance, the Orioles have not scaled back his playing time at all. They have continued to bat him in the middle of the order as if he were having the season he had in Boston before signing with the Orioles. On the days that he does sit, if the opposing team brings in a left-handed reliever, the Orioles cannot sub O'Neill into the game fast enough.

That's what's frustrating. Everyone knows if O'Neill were on a minimum contract, the way he is playing would have gotten him DFA'd a long time ago, but because he got the big contract, he continues to get regular playing time.

Fans want their team to field the best possible lineup to give them a shot at winning. When they see O'Neill in the lineup batting fifth or hear his name announced as a pinch hitter, it doesn't feel like the Orioles are doing that to give themselves a chance to win. Instead, it feels like orders are coming down from the Warehouse insisting that O'Neill continue to get playing time to try to justify the contract that he was given and prove that they didn't make a costly mistake.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow