Surprising Dean Kremer trade provides a blueprint for the Orioles deadline strategy

Baltimore Orioles President of Baseball Operations Mike Elias sat down with the media before the first game of the Orioles series against the Philadelphia Phillies. He gave some insight as to how the Orioles were approaching the upcoming trade deadline. Elias shared that the Orioles front office is not going into the trade deadline with a strong bias towards buying or selling; instead, they were going to check in on the price of players they'd like to buy and field offers on the players they wouldn't mind selling, and then make decisions on a case-by-case basis as far as which path they would go down.

If that seems like an almost meaningless word salad, it is, and that's a cleaned-up version of what Elias said. His actual quotes were far more word salady and meaningless. Hearing Elias explain it almost makes you want to ask him, "What do you mean by that?" and get him to give a straighter answer.

Fortunately for anyone hoping to understand the Orioles' deadline plans, actions speak louder than words, and later that evening the Orioles took action. They traded Dean Kremer to the Minnesota Twins for a low-A prospect named Jhomnardo Reyes. This trade says a lot more about the Orioles' deadline plans than anything Mike Elias said hours earlier.

Dean Kremer has been an important part of the Orioles rotation for years

Kremer had been a long-time staple of the Orioles' rotation. He debuted in 2020 and, after a rough 2021 season, figured things out and locked down a rotation spot for the next several years. From 2022-2025, nobody pitched more innings for the Orioles than Dean Kremer. During that span, he gave the Orioles 599.1 innings at a 3.95 ERA with a 4.17 FIP. He was a metronome of production, a true 4.00 ERA talent who pitched to almost exactly that mark every season. A pitcher with a 4.00 is not exciting, but having one at the back of your rotation that shows up every five days and performs is valuable.

So why would the Orioles trade someone that they had relied on for so long and had been so dependable? There are a few reasons, and as the deadline comes closer, these same reasons are going to come up again and again every time the Orioles make a selling move.

For one, Kremer is nearing the end of his team control. He is a free agent after next season. When the Orioles are deciding who will stay and who will go, years of control are going to matter. That's the basics.

The other reason is that they got what appears to be a really good offer from the Twins. Fangraphs has Jhomnardo Reyes as the Twins #10 prospect and Baseball America has him as their #12 prospect. He's young, he's got enticing tools, and he's tearing up the minors so far. This is not a throwaway, just a guy in a trade so that we get something back kind of prospect. This is a real prospect, and if you had asked most insiders and prospect experts, could the Orioles get a real prospect for Dean Kremer, most people would have said no.

This Orioles front office is very value-driven, and this deadline is going to be a sellers' market where the vast majority of teams in the league are going to be acting like buyers. That means the few teams willing to be sellers should be able to extract really good value from buyers who are a little desperate and frustrated by all of the teams they are talking to asking for their top prospect in exchange for a rental. As the deadline comes closer and teams start to get even more desperate, don't be surprised to see more Orioles moved becuase the front office just can't turn down the value.

The final reason is that the Orioles have a lot of options to backfill what Kremer was giving them. Trey Gibson has already been up and is a comparable talent to Kremer already, with a higher ceiling if he continues to develop. Nestor German is a name that's getting close to a major league call-up who also profiles as a back-end starter. That's not even to mention Chris Bassitt, who should be back soon, and Cade Povich, who's been hanging around the rotation for years.

The Orioles are not going to want to leave a gaping hole on the roster when they trade someone. So what the depth chart looks like is going to matter. If there are upper-minors prospects who play the same position as someone coming up on the end of arbitration, that's a good indicator they could soon be moved.

It'll be interesting to see what the Orioles do next. It will be disappointing if, when they "evaluate buying and selling on a case-by-case basis," the answer to every case is sell. Hopefully some corresponding buying moves will make trading Kremer the setup for an upgrade rather than the team deciding, "we can get by without this guy."

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow