Orioles fans fears might be coming true with top prospect Coby Mayo

The Baltimore Orioles entered the 2025 season with buzzworthy headlines swirling around their pitching staff, trade chips, and postseason aspirations. But perhaps the most intriguing story came not from the mound, but from a frustrated bat stuck in Triple-A. That bat belongs to Coby Mayo.

The 23-year-old slugger, long regarded as one of Baltimore’s potent power-hitting prospects, has been destroying minor league pitching for the better part of two years with the Norfolk Tides. But as Opening Day rosters were finalized, Mayo wasn’t going to be heading to Camden Yards. Instead, he found himself back in Norfolk again. This time, he didn’t keep quiet about it.

“It obviously sucks because you feel like you’ve proven everything you’ve needed to,” Mayo told the Baltimore Banner. “Sometimes it doesn’t feel like it’s quite enough.”

His comments — raw, emotional, and packed with frustration — sparked controversy. While Mayo later clarified that his remarks were not a shot at the Orioles organization, the damage had already been done. Critics pointed to his dismal .098/.196/.098 slash line over 41 big league at-bats last season as proof that he hadn’t earned the right to speak out. His spring wasn’t much better, slashing just .190/.239/.262 — hardly a strong resume.

Still, Mayo has returned to work in Norfolk, and perhaps with defiance, he's begun to turn heads again.

Is Coby Mayo simply a Quad-A hitter — too good for Triple-A, but not quite good enough at the major league level?

Mayo’s talent has never been in question. His 70-grade raw power is real, his arm is a weapon, and his track record in Triple-A speaks for itself. But the question looming large over his career now is one that plagues countless prospects.

Through 14 games, he’s posted a .245/.371/.490 slash line with three home runs and 11 RBIs. But it was his historic hot streak over this past weekend that reignited the conversation: nine straight plate appearances reaching base — a feat rarely seen even at the major league level. For context, Toronto’s Bo Bichette is the only known big leaguer to have done it in a single series in recent memory.

His strikeout rates suggest that might be the case. What he gets away with in Norfolk becomes a liability in the majors. The hit tool — or lack thereof — continues to limit his ceiling. Right now, his profile resembles that of a Jake Bauers-type: a slugger who can fill in at the corners, occasionally mash a fastball into orbit, and just maybe run into a hot streak that justifies a roster spot.

That kind of player can survive — thrive, even — in some organizations. But not in Baltimore. Not with the logjam of talent the Orioles have across the infield and corner outfield spots. For Mayo to break through, the margin for error is razor thin. The strikeouts must be cut down. The hot streaks must arrive sooner and last longer.

The Orioles have reason to believe in Mayo. And if he continues to rake in Triple-A, another opportunity will certainly come. But when that call-up happens, the bat will have to speak for itself. Because the next time Coby Mayo gets a taste of the majors, it might be his last chance in Baltimore to prove he belongs.