Mike Elias can't escape the backlash as Orioles rookie flourishes

For Baltimore Orioles fans, Dylan Beavers wasn’t just a name on a prospect list, he’s been the guy for most of the 2025 season. The hitter-in-waiting whose bat was too loud to ignore. So when the Orioles finally called up their top outfield prospect on August 16, it wasn’t met with a parade or dramatic reveal. It was met with an exhausted eye-roll and a collective: “About time.”

After all, by mid-August, the Orioles had been out of the playoff conversation longer than your group chat had been planning that beach trip. The outfield depth was already decimated, Ramon Laureano, Cedric Mullins, and Ryan O’Hearn were all traded. And there sat Dylan Beavers, still absolutely torching Triple-A pitching to the tune of a .304 average and .934 OPS over 94 games, waiting for a phone call that felt like it might never come.

Mike Elias faces the music as Orioles rookie Dylan Beavers shines

The ire of the fanbase didn’t just center around Beavers being left in Norfolk. It was about what the delay represented — another case of front office maneuvering that felt more concerned with service time manipulation than fielding the best possible team.

General Manager Mike Elias, once applauded for engineering the Orioles’ farm system revival, was now catching heat across Reddit threads and fan radio call-ins. Fans were furious that he chose service time gamesmanship over giving a depleted roster the spark it desperately needed.

To be fair, this wasn’t a mystery. Fans knew Beavers was ready. Analysts believed he was ready. And now, Beavers has made it abundantly clear that he was.

In just 17 games, Beavers has looked like he belongs, and then some. He’s slashing .302/.431/.434 with a 144 OPS+, one home run, six RBIs, and 16 hits. He even swiped a bag just to sprinkle in a little chaos. But it’s not just the raw numbers, it’s how he’s doing it.

Yes, the 27.7 percent strikeout rate raises an eyebrow, but that’s not uncommon for rookies adjusting to major-league arms. What offsets it in a big way is his elite 18.5 percent walk rate, showcasing advanced plate discipline and pitch recognition well beyond most players with “rookie” in their bio.

He’s not flailing. He’s not overwhelmed. He’s not searching for answers. He’s executing a plan, and that’s the kind of maturity that makes fans shake their heads wondering why he wasn't here sooner.

What if he was promoted in June? Or right after the All-Star break? Could the Orioles have snapped out of their season-long spiral sooner? Could they have salvaged their standing in a relatively weak Wild Card race? We’ll never know, and that ambiguity will haunt Elias longer than any service-time benefit might reward him.

So no, this isn’t just about a hot streak or a feel-good rookie story. This is about accountability, and fans being right. They saw what Elias didn’t, or at least what he pretended not to see, and now they’re watching Beavers deliver everything they expected.

More Orioles News from Birds Watcher