Trying to decipher who the Baltimore Orioles are actually going to acquire this offseason may make your head spin. Over the past week, the Orioles have been connected to a litany of free agents, and Orioles players have been mentioned numerous times on the trade market; that trend continued.
ESPN's David Schoenfield wrote a piece ranking every team's chance at Tarik Skubal, while also giving backup options. The Orioles were pretty obviously ranked lower on this list; though they were in the top 20, the backup options the senior baseball writer listed were not overly inspiring.
Schoenfield gave three options: one Orioles fans have heard a few times, Kevin Gausman, and two newer names: right-handers Nick Pivetta and Tyler Mahle. While the Orioles could use one more back-end rotation arm, given the injury history of their current rotation, those names don't really fit the bill.
The Orioles can't take risks on pitchers with injury histories, no matter the upside
So we've got @afkostka reporting the Orioles have interest in LHPs Kris Bubic, Matthew Boyd and David Peterson
— SleeperOrioles (@SleeperOrioles) November 16, 2026
Then we've got David Schoenfield of ESPN saying guys like Kevin Gausman, Tyler Mahle and Nick Pivetta fit the mold of what Baltimore' looking for
Talk about a wide… pic.twitter.com/z2ohKbnBe3
Former Padres and Red Sox starter Nick Pivetta is a free agent for the second time in his career. In. Boston, he was a solid back-end arm, providing upwards of 145 innings in each of his four full seasons with the team, and posting ERAs in the mid-to-low fours. His first season in San Diego was a breakout for the former fourth-round pick, pitching 181 innings with a 2.87 ERA and a 6th-place Cy Young finish. The pitcher-friendly Petco Park helped him keep the ball in the yard much more.
In 2026, the righty barely pitched. Pivetta made just eight starts. Right elbow inflammation shut him down from mid-April until he returned to the majors on September 7. Throwing arm issues are always concerning, which makes Pivetta a risky move for a team needing health in their rotation. Another thing to consider: Pivetta struggles with allowing the long ball, and according to Park Factor, Camden Yards has been a home run-friendly park the last three seasons.
The other new name that Schoenfield suggested was veteran journeyman Tyler Mahle. The 32-year-old is coming off a polarizing season. After signing a one-year deal with San Francisco in the offseason, he pitched to a 5.13 ERA in 18 starts for the Giants. He was dealt at the trade deadline to the Braves, though, and he completely turned around his season. After the trade, Mahle's ERA dropped to 1.99 in 9 starts, and he dropped his BB% from 9.2 to 4.3.
Teams are going to bet that Mahle will be able to carry over the fixes he got in Atlanta, with most media outlets projecting he'll get a multi-year deal this offseason. The biggest issue with the righty is his extended injury history. Injuries plagued every season from 2022 to 2025 for Mahle. He was finally able to pitch more than 100 innings in 2026 for the first time since 2022, and his 27 starts were the most since he made 33 in 2021.
The Orioles need to be looking for pitchers who will offer stability in the rotation. While they have a cast of top pitching prospects, none will likely be ready until later in the season, and Baltimore's major league starting depth is thin. Instead of betting on potential upside, they need pitchers they feel better about being healthy in 2027.
