MLB's deadline to protect players from the Rule 5 draft is November 17 at 6 P.M. EST. Any player who is eligible for the draft needs to be added to their respective team's 40-man roster, or the team risks losing them, basically for nothing. That means the Baltimore Orioles have some work to do.
As of November 16, the Orioles have 37 players on their 40-man roster. That leaves a few open spots to protect some of their prospects. Unless Mike Elias wants to DFA a few players, though, he may end up losing some of their top minor leaguers.
Five of Baltimore's MLB Pipeline top-30 prospects are Rule 5 eligible this offseason. It's not often that a team protects five players and fills up their roster. One route GMs take is trading some of those players to teams who will add them to their 40-man roster before the deadline to try and jump the Rule 5 draft. Instead of hoping the player falls to them in the draft, the team will trade a prospect to acquire them early. Here are some players that Elias could choose to take that route with instead of protecting them.
3 Orioles prospects who could be traded instead of protected before the Rule 5 deadline
OF Enrique Bradfield Jr. - No. 18
The 2023 first-round pick has not been able to crack the Orioles outfield. The soft-hitting center fielder played most of 2026 in Triple-A. While he showed off his contact skills and on-base ability in his 88 games (.263 batting average and .344 on-base percentage), he was unable to hit for power, with just 20 extra-base hits.
The Orioles need major upgrades in the outfield this offseason, and in their current competitive window, they don't have time to see if Bradfield will develop. They already have their center fielder in Colton Cowser as well. Another outfield-needy team could see a plus defender in center, who can get on base and swipe a lot of bags (36 steals in Triple-A this season) as a player worth trading for. The Orioles don't have time for him to develop, and it makes way more sense to trade him than leave him unprotected for the draft.
C/1B Creed Willems - No. 28
An eighth-round pick in 2021, Willems made AAA for the first time in 2026 and performed really well. He slashed .254/.347/.414, hitting 19 home runs and 67 RBIs. There are questions about his ability to stick behind the plate defensively, and only 57% of his starts were at catcher in 2026, with 24% being at first base and the rest at DH.
While a potential power threat like Willems could be helpful for the Orioles in the future, they already have his positions locked up long term. Samuel Basallo has a similar question being asked about his position, and he does the C/1B/DH split too; they acquired Carlos Narvaez at the deadline, and Pete Alonso is locked in at first. Some are wondering if the Orioles will add another catcher in free agency too. Willems doesn't have a role on the roster at the moment, and instead of making a logjam, or losing him for nothings, Elias should find a trade partner who does want his archetype.
RHP Nestor German - No. 21
The Orioles have done an excellent job cultivating young pitching talent in the last few years. Eight of their top 15 prospects are pitchers, and there are another six in the 16-30 range. One of those in the back half is former 11th-round pick Nestor German. The 24-year-old has back-to-back solid seasons, making 47 starts (plus three relief outings) and pitching 240 2/3 innings with a combined 4.00 ERA across High-A, Double-A, and Triple-A.
While the Orioles are still looking to build their rotation, a player like German likely won't make enough of an impact in 2027. He could be a depth arm, but the O's have a lot of pitchers not far from the majors with higher prospect status, and they could use that roster spot more than German. It would be better to trade him now, instead of letting a pitching-needy team take their chance on him in the Rule 5 Draft.
