Courtesy of USA Today

Does the Orioles' success bank of Wieters?

The at-times “chilly relationship between agent Scott Boras and the Baltimore Orioles has been well documented over the years. Many people argue that the Orioles don’t want to play Boras’ game, and that’s almost a death sentence in today’s MLB. I would submit that Boras can be tough to deal with, although I’ll grant you that I’ve never actually met the man. However I suppose to his credit he pulls out any stops necessary to get the best deals for his clients. For instance, in 1996 he used an obscure provision in the MLB draft rules to have two of his clients declared free agents after they were drafted by the Giants and ChiSox respectively. Both players later signed with the expansion Tampa Bay (Devil) Rays. (That rule has since been changed, specifically due to Boras.)

One mark of a Boras client is that they legendarily tend not to sign extensions. Boras would rather his clients hit the open market and then get the best deal from any team as opposed to “risking” the act of taking a hometown discount. His thought is that signing an extension with one’s original team is probably going to net the player less than he would get on the open market. The impression of course is that Boras “plays favorites” in the Yankees and Red Sox. I would think that’s probably not the case; Boras plays favorites on a case-by-case basis with whomever pays his clients the most. They just happen to be two of those teams.

Both Chris Davis and Matt Wieters are Boras clients, so somewhat of a showdown between Boras and the Orioles is on the horizon. The O’s took a great first step in offering a $10.25 million contract for Chris Davis two weeks ago that Boras jumped on. That establishes somewhat of a lifeline between the two sides. However for the time being it appears that the O’s are headed to arbitration with Matt Wieters. Now ultimately I don’t think it’ll end up there, however another mark of Scott Boras is that he doesn’t forget. I take that back – he seems to have a short memory when people accomodate him. So if he comes away with the perception that the Orioles are low-balling his client (Wieters), it might well erase any good tidings that came from Davis’ contract.

Ideally, the Orioles could just offer both players much-better-than-fair contract extensions to make Boras think a bit. However if Boras ends up in an offended state of mind due to Wieters’ contract, does he even take Dan Duquette’s call if it comes? One would hope so. One would also hope that he might find just a bit of rationality in a sense given that if the Orioles’ offer is that good he’ll take it. The risk of course is that five minutes after either player is a free agent they’re signed with another team with the Orioles’ offer (from who knows how long ago) having been used as leverage to get a higher price from another team.

While Boras might come off as a bit vengeful at times, he is a decent businessman. So I’m not sure he’d just leave the Orioles hanging on either player without calling back to see if they have another offer. But my point is that it might behoove the Orioles to play ball with Boras just a bit on Wieters, as disgraceful as it might seem. For the record, Mark Texeira’s contract comes off of New York’s books the same year as Davis is a free agent. Davis is probably a player the Orioles can’t afford to lose.

Next Orioles Game View full schedule »
Wednesday, Aug 2727 Aug7:05Tampa Bay RaysBuy Tickets

Tags: Baltimore Orioles Chris Davis Matt Wieters

  • Dave Gruber

    At the risk of offending a lot of O’s fans here is my simple answer to the headline of the article-I sure hope not. I want to start by saying I believe he is an above average catcher but certainly not one of the top 5 or 6 in the game. He receives a lot if credit for the percentage of base runners he throws out and also for how few even attempt to run on him. I submit that the credit for that should go to the pitchers for doing a good job holding runners on base and delivering the pitch quickly to the plate. There aren’t any catchers in MLB who don’t have strong arms, the difference is they don’t have a manager that makes it a priority to his staff to hold runners close and get the ball quickly to home. Buck does that. As far as offense goes I’ll just say at least it was a productive .235 he hit last year. I don’t want to come across as a Weiters basher, ad I said at the beginning I do think he is above average but any honest O’s fan has to admit to being somewhat disappointed with the guy Sports Illustrated called “Joe Mauer with power.” The biggest thing Matt has going for him, and believe me Scott Boras knows this, is that the O’s have no other catcher even close to being able to step in and take over if something were to happen to him. Unless he finally has a season where he reaches his offensive potential I would get into a bidding war to keep him after 2015.

    • Dave Gruber

      Obviously I didnt proofread my comments before submitting them. I of course meant to say I would NOT get into a bidding war for Weiters after the 2015 season.